process
Pillar Fit Diagnostic (Pre-Sale Evaluation)
Lightweight strategic evaluation for early prospect conversations. Identifies which pillars are likely to resonate based on industry patterns, business model, maturity stage, and strategic priorities. Provides hypothesis-driven framing before committing to full SRA engagement.
Purpose
The Pillar Fit Diagnostic is a 15-minute strategic screen that accomplishes three goals:
- For us: Hypothesis about which pillars will resonate before investing in full SRA
- For prospect: Early value demonstrationβwe're thinking strategically, not just selling automation
- For conversation: Framework to guide discovery call toward highest-value topics
This is NOT a replacement for the SRA. It's a pre-qualification and conversation-shaping tool.
When to Use
| Situation | Use Pillar Fit? |
|---|---|
| Cold outreach response / first meeting | β Yes |
| Inbound inquiry before scoping call | β Yes |
| Referral introduction | β Yes |
| Prospect already committed to SRA | β Skip to SRA |
| RFP response | β οΈ Adapt to RFP context |
The Diagnostic Framework
Part 1: Industry Pattern Recognition
Different industries have predictable pillar affinities based on their value chain structure:
| Industry | Primary Pillar | Secondary | Rationale |
|---|---|---|---|
| Manufacturing | P3 (Predictive) | P1 (Service) | Equipment uptime is existential; aftermarket services are margin |
| Distribution/Logistics | P3 (Predictive) | P2 (Data) | Supply chain resilience; demand/routing data valuable |
| Professional Services | P1 (Service) | P2 (Data) | Client retention is everything; expertise can be productized |
| Healthcare | P3 (Predictive) | P1 (Service) | Outcome prediction; patient engagement/adherence |
| Financial Services | P3 (Predictive) | P2 (Data) | Risk/fraud prevention; customer insight monetization |
| Insurance (Agency) | P1 (Service) | P2 (Data) | Retention in commoditized market; carrier/customer data |
| Insurance (Carrier) | P3 (Predictive) | P2 (Data) | Loss prevention; actuarial data products |
| SaaS/Technology | P1 (Service) | P3 (Predictive) | Scale success; churn prevention; platform value |
| Retail/E-commerce | P2 (Data) | P1 (Service) | Retail media opportunity; personalization |
| Construction | P3 (Predictive) | P1 (Service) | Project risk; maintenance services |
| Real Estate | P1 (Service) | P2 (Data) | Client lifecycle; market data |
Usage: Industry gives you a starting hypothesis. Validate with maturity and strategy questions.
β οΈ TECH/SAAS NOTE: Tech and SaaS companies require different framing. See "SaaS-Specific Signals" section below. The baseline assumptions differβthey're already digital-native, data-rich, and subscription-based.
Part 1B: SaaS-Specific Signals (Tech Companies Only)
For SaaS/Tech companies, the standard pillar signals don't apply directly. Use these instead:
SaaS P1 Signals (Service β Scaled Success)
| Signal | Indicator | Pillar Fit |
|---|---|---|
| NRR < 100% | Contraction/churn exceeds expansion | P1 High |
| CSM ratio > 1:100 | Under-resourced customer success | P1 High |
| Moving upmarket | SMB β Mid-Market β Enterprise | P1 High |
| Feature parity with competitors | Can't differentiate on product | P1 High |
| Enterprise deals stalling | "Not ready for enterprise" feedback | P1 High |
SaaS P2 Signals (Data β Platform Value)
| Signal | Indicator | Pillar Fit |
|---|---|---|
| No benchmark product | Customers ask "how do I compare?" | P2 High |
| Platform aspirations | Want to be ecosystem, not point solution | P2 High |
| Pricing uncertainty | Don't know value of usage tiers | P2 High |
| Competitor catching up | Feature parity race; need moat | P2 High |
| Acquisition integration | Multiple products, fragmented data | P2 High |
SaaS P3 Signals (Prediction β Scaled Prevention)
| Signal | Indicator | Pillar Fit |
|---|---|---|
| Prediction-action gap | Have churn model; can't act on it | P3 High |
| Bolt-on analytics | Dashboards exist; don't prevent | P3 High |
| Infrastructure incidents | Downtime/performance surprises | P3 High |
| Support overwhelm | Reactive tickets; no prevention | P3 High |
| Champion risk | Key users leave; account follows | P3 High |
SaaS Discovery Questions
- "What's your NRR? Where does expansion come from?"
- "What's your CSM-to-account ratio? How do you prioritize?"
- "Have customers asked 'how do I compare to peers'?"
- "You have a churn modelβwhat happens after it flags an account?"
- "What's your platform strategy? Where does data fit?"
SaaS Framing Shifts
| Pillar | DON'T Say | DO Say |
|---|---|---|
| P1 | "Create recurring revenue" | "Scale success without scaling headcount" |
| P2 | "Start using your data" | "Build data moat before competitors" |
| P3 | "Build prediction capability" | "Close the prediction-to-action gap" |
Part 2: Maturity Stage Assessment
Company lifecycle stage affects which pillar creates most urgent value:
| Stage | Indicators | Likely Pillar Priority | Rationale |
|---|---|---|---|
| Growth | Scaling fast, acquisition focus, hiring | P1 β P3 | Retention before more acquisition; don't scale chaos |
| Mature/Stable | Established market, predictable revenue | P2 β P1 | New revenue from existing assets; deepen relationships |
| Turnaround | Declining metrics, cost pressure | P3 β P1 | Stop bleeding first; then retention |
| PE-Backed (Growth thesis) | Revenue growth targets, add-on acquisitions | P1 β P2 | CLV expansion; platform value creation |
| PE-Backed (Margin thesis) | EBITDA targets, operational efficiency | P3 β P2 | Loss reduction; high-margin data products |
| PE-Backed (Exit prep) | 12-24 month horizon | P1 β P2 | Recurring revenue metrics; strategic asset narrative |
| Pre-IPO | S-1 prep, governance focus | P3 β P1 | Risk/compliance; customer metrics |
Discovery Questions:
- "What's your primary focus for the next 18 monthsβgrowth, profitability, or risk reduction?"
- "Are you PE-backed? What's the investment thesis timeline?"
- "How does your board measure success?"
Part 3: Business Model Signals
Current business model reveals transformation potential:
| Current Model | Pillar Opportunity | Transformation Path |
|---|---|---|
| Transaction/project-based | P1 (High) | Transaction β Relationship |
| Subscription/recurring | P2, P3 (High) | Already P1; optimize or expand |
| Break-fix/reactive service | P1, P3 (High) | Reactive β Proactive/Managed |
| Product + support | P1 (High) | Product β Platform |
| Data-rich operations | P2 (High) | Byproduct β Asset |
| High-touch consultative | P2 (Medium) | Expertise β Scalable IP |
| Commodity/price competition | P1 (High) | Escape commodity trap via service |
Discovery Questions:
- "What percentage of revenue is recurring vs. one-time?"
- "After the initial sale, what's the typical customer relationship look like?"
- "What do customers call you about?"
Part 4: Strategic Priority Signals
Explicit priorities reveal pillar alignment:
| If they say... | Pillar Signal | Follow-up Probe |
|---|---|---|
| "We need to grow revenue" | P1 or P2 | "From existing customers or new?" |
| "We're losing customers" | P1 | "What's driving churn?" |
| "Margins are under pressure" | P2 or P3 | "Cost side or pricing power?" |
| "We keep getting surprised" | P3 | "What kind of surprises?" |
| "We're sitting on data we don't use" | P2 | "What decisions could it inform?" |
| "Customers want more from us" | P1 | "What are they asking for?" |
| "We can't scale our best people" | P1 or P2 | "What do they do that others can't?" |
| "Quality/errors are killing us" | P3 | "What's the cost of a typical incident?" |
| "We're too reactive" | P3 | "What would proactive look like?" |
Part 5: Pillar Fit Matrix
Synthesize findings into a prioritization:
PILLAR FIT ASSESSMENT
Company: _____________________
Industry: ____________________
Stage: _______________________
SIGNALS
βββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββ
β Industry β Maturity β Model β Priority β
ββββββββββββββββββΌβββββββββββΌβββββββββββΌββββββββΌβββββββββββ€
β P1: Service β H/M/L β H/M/L β H/M/L β H/M/L β
ββββββββββββββββββΌβββββββββββΌβββββββββββΌββββββββΌβββββββββββ€
β P2: Data β H/M/L β H/M/L β H/M/L β H/M/L β
ββββββββββββββββββΌβββββββββββΌβββββββββββΌββββββββΌβββββββββββ€
β P3: Predictive β H/M/L β H/M/L β H/M/L β H/M/L β
ββββββββββββββββββ΄βββββββββββ΄βββββββββββ΄ββββββββ΄βββββββββββ
SYNTHESIS:
βββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββ
β Lead Pillar: P__ β
β Secondary: P__ β
β Confidence: High / Medium / Low β
β Key Hypothesis: _______________________________________ β
βββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββ
Output: Conversation Framework
Based on Pillar Fit, select the appropriate conversation opener:
If P1 (Service-ization) Leads:
Opening frame: "Most companies in [industry] leave money on the table after the initial sale. The relationship ends when it should be deepening. We help companies turn one-time transactions into ongoing relationshipsβwithout adding headcount."
Key questions to ask:
- What happens after a customer buys from you?
- What percentage of customers buy again? What drives that?
- What would your customers pay for if you could offer it profitably?
Proof points to have ready:
- CLV improvement examples
- AI customer service cost curves
- Industry-specific service-ization case
If P2 (Data Assetization) Leads:
Opening frame: "You're generating data every day that could be a productβor at least a decision-making advantage. Most companies treat data as exhaust. We help turn it into inventory."
Key questions to ask:
- What data do you generate that you don't fully use?
- What decisions do you make repeatedly that could be informed by patterns?
- Have customers or partners ever asked for access to your data or insights?
Proof points to have ready:
- Mid-market data monetization examples
- Operational vs. external monetization distinction
- Data infrastructure ROI benchmarks
If P3 (Predictive Resilience) Leads:
Opening frame: "Every company has 'surprises' that weren't really surprisingβthe signals were there, you just couldn't see them in time. We help companies shift from firefighting to prevention."
Key questions to ask:
- What was your last major operational surprise? What did it cost?
- What problems do your best people catch early that others miss?
- If you could have a warning light for one thing, what would it predict?
Proof points to have ready:
- Prevention ROI methodology
- Prediction accuracy by use case
- Traditional vs. AI detection comparison
Integration with SRA
The Pillar Fit Diagnostic shapes SRA administration:
| Pillar Fit Result | SRA Emphasis |
|---|---|
| P1 leads | Deep dive on Section 8.1 (Service-ization); probe Section 2 for "what would you offer if you could?" |
| P2 leads | Deep dive on Section 6.2 (Data Assets), Section 8.2 (Data Assetization); probe for unstructured data |
| P3 leads | Deep dive on Section 7 (Silent Attrition), Section 8.3 (Predictive); probe for "surprises" |
| Balanced/unclear | Full SRA with equal weight; let data determine |
Quick Reference Card
5 Questions to Determine Pillar Fit:
- Industry: "What industry are you in?" β Check industry pattern table
- Stage: "What's your primary focusβgrowth, profitability, or risk reduction?" β Check maturity table
- Model: "What percentage of revenue is recurring?" β Check business model table
- Pain: "What's the biggest problem you're trying to solve?" β Check priority signals
- Validate: "If I said [lead pillar hypothesis], does that resonate?" β Confirm or pivot
Time: 10-15 minutes in conversation Output: Lead pillar + conversation framework
Version History
| Version | Date | Changes |
|---|---|---|
| 1.0 | 2026-01-03 | Initial framework |